The PCOS Diet’s Unfulfilled Promise

by Ella
healthy diet

In the realm of health and wellness, diets often promise transformative outcomes, offering hope to those grappling with chronic conditions. Polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS), a hormonal disorder affecting millions of women in the United States, has long been a target for such dietary interventions, especially for those who are overweight. Advocates touted restrictive diets as a means to alleviate symptoms, but recent revelations cast doubt on the effectiveness of this approach.

In 2018, a prominent group of PCOS experts suggested that overweight or obese individuals with the condition could benefit from reducing their caloric intake by up to 750 calories per day. This recommendation fueled the proliferation of questionable diet programs on social media platforms and fostered a belief among PCOS sufferers that dietary modifications alone could lead to significant improvements.


However, critical examination reveals that these recommendations lacked robust scientific evidence to support their efficacy. Research now suggests that sustained weight loss through restrictive dieting is challenging for most individuals, and those with PCOS face even greater obstacles. Julie Duffy Dillon, a registered dietitian specializing in PCOS care, asserts that the connection between long-term weight loss and improved symptoms remains uncertain and inadequately established.


In 2023, the International PCOS Network, recognizing the need for updated guidance, revised its recommendations based on a comprehensive analysis of current research. The group abandoned references to caloric restriction and instead advocated for a balanced and healthy dietary composition akin to the Mediterranean diet. This dietary approach is associated with mitigating the health risks associated with PCOS, such as cardiovascular disease and diabetes, although its potential impact on PCOS symptoms remains unconfirmed.


Dr. Helena Teede, an endocrinologist at Monash Health in Australia and lead author of the 2023 guidelines, emphasizes that these revisions reflect both the evolving PCOS literature and the lived experiences of individuals with the condition. The focus has shifted away from assigning blame or stigmatizing individuals, acknowledging that weight management is a complex issue influenced by various factors beyond personal behavior.


Understanding Polycystic Ovary Syndrome

PCOS is a multifaceted hormonal disorder affecting approximately five million women in the United States. Its manifestations include irregular periods, infertility, excessive facial hair growth, acne, and scalp hair loss, which can overlap with symptoms of other health conditions, complicating diagnosis. Individuals with PCOS often experience infrequent ovulation and elevated levels of androgens or multiple underdeveloped follicles on their ovaries, rather than cysts as the name suggests.

Typically, diagnosis involves ovarian scans or blood tests to assess hormone levels. While there is no cure for PCOS, the primary treatment approach often involves some form of birth control to regulate menstrual cycles.

Beyond its reproductive implications, PCOS can impact metabolic health, including blood sugar, blood pressure, and cholesterol levels. Chronic inflammation, a common occurrence among PCOS sufferers, increases the risk of cardiovascular disease, endometrial cancer, and diabetes. Additionally, individuals with PCOS are more susceptible to mental health issues such as depression, anxiety, suicide attempts, and eating disorders.

Navigating the Weight Conundrum

The relationship between PCOS and weight is intricate, with obesity strongly linked to the condition. Dr. Anuja Dokras, director of the Penn Polycystic Ovary Syndrome Center at the University of Pennsylvania, underscores the bidirectional nature of this relationship, yet the underlying mechanisms remain unclear.

Obesity rates among PCOS patients vary globally, indicating a complex interplay of genetic and environmental factors. While some studies suggest that lifestyle-induced weight loss may ameliorate hormonal and metabolic symptoms, evidence regarding fertility outcomes remains inconclusive.

Recent studies examining the impact of bariatric surgery on obese women with PCOS offer intriguing insights. Dr. Dokras highlights evidence showing regular menstrual cycles and reduced levels of male hormones post-surgery, suggesting a potential link between weight loss and symptom improvement. However, research into the efficacy of weight loss medications such as Ozempic for PCOS management is ongoing.

Challenges abound for individuals with PCOS and insulin resistance, where ineffective insulin utilization leads to elevated blood sugar levels. This exacerbates symptoms, including weight gain, and impedes weight loss efforts, according to Dr. Heather Huddleston, director of the PCOS Clinic and research program at the University of California, San Francisco.

Julie Duffy Dillon underscores the harmful impact of calorie-restrictive diets, particularly considering the heightened prevalence of eating disorders among PCOS patients. She notes the detrimental effects of failed diet attempts, often leading to feelings of personal responsibility and subsequent disengagement from healthcare services.

Moving Forward with Compassion and Understanding

As the landscape of PCOS management evolves, there is a growing recognition of the need for compassionate and holistic approaches. Acknowledging the complexities of PCOS and its impact on physical and mental health is essential in providing effective care and support to those affected by this condition.

With ongoing research and evolving guidelines, the focus shifts from blame to empowerment, emphasizing individualized care and addressing the multifaceted needs of PCOS patients. By fostering a supportive environment and prioritizing evidence-based interventions, healthcare professionals can better serve the diverse and unique needs of individuals navigating the complexities of PCOS.



Wellfoodrecipes is a professional gourmet portal, the main columns include gourmet recipes, healthy diet, desserts, festival recipes, meat and seafood recipes, etc.

【Contact us: [email protected]

Copyright © 2023